Setauket-East Setauket
Welcome to Setauket-East Setauket, NY: A Community Steeped in History
Walk the streets of Setauket and East Setauket, and you'll feel the profound presence of American history. Nestled on the scenic North Shore of Long Island, this charming area, collectively known as "The Setaukets," offers a unique living experience where colonial heritage and modern life seamlessly intertwine. Renowned for its pivotal role in the American Revolution, its exceptional schools, and its stunning natural beauty, Setauket-East Setauket is a community that offers not just a home, but a piece of the nation's story.
A Legacy of Spies and Patriots
Founded in 1655, Setauket is one of the earliest settlements on Long Island. Its place in history was forever cemented during the American Revolution. This quiet farming community became the operational center for the Culper Spy Ring, a clandestine group of residents organized by Major Benjamin Tallmadge under the orders of George Washington. From 1778 to 1783, spies like Abraham Woodhull risked their lives to gather intelligence on British troops in New York City, famously using methods like Anna Smith Strong's clothesline signals to relay critical information. This intelligence was instrumental in turning the tide of the war. Today, this incredible history is preserved and celebrated, with many original structures still standing in the Old Setauket Historic District.
A Community of Charm and Character
The Setaukets foster a strong, intellectually vibrant community feel, deeply influenced by its rich past and the proximity of Stony Brook University. The area is marked by a palpable sense of pride in its unique identity, distinguishing itself with a quieter, more historic character than its bustling neighbors. Residents value the friendly, small-town atmosphere, the abundance of green space, and the active community life, supported by outstanding institutions like the Emma S. Clark Memorial Library and the Three Village Historical Society, which offers tours of the area's most storied locations.
Architectural Heritage and Waterfront Homes
The architectural landscape of Setauket-East Setauket is a captivating journey through time. The historic district features a stunning collection of beautifully preserved 17th and 18th-century Colonial and Saltbox homes. Driving through the area reveals a diverse array of styles, including stately Victorians, classic Capes, and sprawling mid-century Ranches. The waterfront areas along Setauket Harbor and Little Bay are lined with magnificent homes, offering spectacular views and a serene coastal lifestyle. This rich variety ensures a home for every taste, from historic purists to those seeking modern comfort.
Real Estate in The Setaukets: A Snapshot of a Desirable Market
The real estate market in Setauket-East Setauket is highly competitive, reflecting the area's immense appeal. As of summer 2025, demand remains strong for its unique blend of history, top-tier schools, and coastal charm.
Historic Properties and Modern Comforts: The housing market offers a broad range of options. Recent trends in mid-2025 show a median sale price of approximately $776,000, with prices climbing based on location, size, and historical significance. The market is very active, with homes often selling quickly. Properties here cater to those who appreciate character and quality living, from character-filled historic houses to updated family homes in quiet, leafy developments.
Unmatched Amenities and Natural Beauty
Setauket-East Setauket offers a wealth of amenities that enhance its high quality of life.
A Premier School District: The community is served by the acclaimed Three Village Central School District, which is consistently ranked among the best in New York State. The district's commitment to academic excellence makes it a primary draw for families moving to the area.
Parks, Preserves, and Beaches: Outdoor enthusiasts will find no shortage of activities. The Frank Melville Memorial Park, with its picturesque mill pond, is a local treasure. The Setauket-to-Port Jefferson Station Greenway Trail provides miles of paved paths for walking and biking, while the Laurel Ridge Setauket Woods Nature Preserve offers extensive hiking trails. Nearby, West Meadow Beach and Cedar Beach provide beautiful shorelines for swimming, kayaking, and relaxation.
Proximity to Stony Brook and Port Jefferson: The neighborhood benefits from its close proximity to Stony Brook University, which provides access to cultural events, and the vibrant Village of Port Jefferson, known for its eclectic shops, diverse dining scene, and ferry service to Connecticut.
Convenient Connectivity: Commuting is accessible via the Stony Brook and Port Jefferson stations on the Long Island Rail Road. Major roadways provide convenient travel throughout Long Island, making it easy to access both the urban centers to the west and the wineries and beaches of the East End.
Setauket-East Setauket offers a rare opportunity to live in a community that is rich in history, dedicated to education, and surrounded by natural splendor, creating an engaging and deeply rewarding environment to call home.
HOA: No (The majority of classic and historic homes do not have a neighborhood-wide HOA. However, newer condominium and private developments within the area will have their own HOAs.) 55+ Community: No (While the area is not a designated 55+ community, it is home to several desirable 55+ active adult developments that offer a variety of amenities.)
